I’ve been wearing Faherty clothing for about a year now, and people keep asking me whether it’s worth the price. Fair question — their shirts run $100+, shorts hover around $80-90, and outerwear can push past $300. That’s not impulse-buy territory for most people.
So here’s my honest take after putting their gear through a full four seasons of wear.
What Is Faherty?
Faherty is a premium lifestyle brand founded by twin brothers Alex and Mike Faherty in 2013. Their whole thing is sustainable, high-quality basics — the kind of clothes you’re supposed to reach for every single day. They use organic cotton, recycled materials, and responsible manufacturing. The vibe sits somewhere between coastal casual and refined everyday wear.
If you’ve ever searched for Faherty clothing online, you’ve probably noticed the brand popping up in menswear roundups alongside names like Vuori, Marine Layer, and Billy Reid. They compete in that “elevated casual” space that’s exploded post-pandemic.
Quality and Materials
This is where Faherty earns its price tag. The fabrics feel noticeably different from what you’ll find at J.Crew or Banana Republic. Their signature Legend sweater knit is probably the softest thing I own — it feels broken-in from day one but hasn’t degraded after dozens of washes.
Their button-downs use a brushed cotton that drapes better than most shirts at twice the price. The stitching is clean, the buttons feel substantial, and the collars hold their shape. I’ve had a Faherty flannel for over a year with zero pilling.
The Brand sustainability program means every piece uses at least one sustainable material or process. It’s not just marketing copy — you can actually feel the difference in the fabric weight and texture.
Fit and Sizing
Faherty runs true to size with a slightly relaxed fit. If you’re between sizes, I’d say stay true — the slight ease in the cut is part of the appeal. Their shorts hit right above the knee (7″ inseam on most styles), and their tees have a boxy-but-not-oversized silhouette that works on most body types.
One thing worth noting: their pants tend to run about a half-inch generous in the waist. Not enough to size down, but worth knowing if you’re between sizes.
What I’d Improve
The price is the obvious barrier. A $128 button-down is a tough sell when you can get “good enough” from Target for $30. You’re paying for sustainability, superior fabric, and longevity — but that premium is real.
Their online-only model means you can’t try things on before buying. The return process is smooth, but it adds friction.
Is Faherty Worth It?
If you value quality over quantity and want a wardrobe of pieces that genuinely last, yes. I’ve replaced four “cheap” shirts with two Faherty shirts and I reach for the Faherty every time. Cost-per-wear, they’re actually competitive with fast fashion over a 2-3 year window.
If you want to try them without the full sticker shock, I have a Faherty discount code — use LMM20 for 20% off your order. That brings their entry-level tees down to around $50, which is much easier to stomach as a first purchase.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Faherty clothing shrink after the first wash?
Faherty only employs high-grade organic cotton fabric and custom knits, meaning their shrinkage rates are minimal, typically less than 2-3%. To maintain original fit, I advise washing in cold water and hanging to dry; or alternatively, you may prefer using your dryer on low heat settings to protect “Legend’s” signature softness.
How does Faherty sizing compare to brands like J.Crew or Marine Layer?
Faherty clothing typically offers a “Tailored Relaxed” fit similar to J.Crew’s Slim fit; however, Faherty tends to provide slightly more generous chest and shoulder room than its competitor for everyday movement comfort. If you wear an 8 or Medium in Marine Layer apparel, Faherty offers similar yet slightly structured silhouette.
What exactly is the “Legend” fabric everyone talks about?
Faherty’s Legend Sweater Knit fabric is one of its trademark products, constructed using polyester, viscose, and spandex blends that emulate classic flannel yet feel soft, stretchy clouds. Known for being extremely wrinkle-resistant while maintaining its shape better than regular 100% cotton shirts, The Legend Sweater Knit has earned itself quite the renown over time!
Is Faherty considered a “Fast Fashion” brand?
Absolutely not. Faherty is an advocate of Slow Fashion, emphasizing quality over quantity by employing recycled polyester, organic cotton and linen in their apparel production processes. In addition, their Second Wave program for reselling preloved items supports Faherty’s commitment to keeping clothes out of landfills while producing pieces designed to outlive trends – not seasons – long term.
Are Faherty shorts worth the $90 price tag?
If you are looking for versatility, absolutely. With their hidden drawstring and quick-dry fabric design, these shorts serve as both high-end casual walk shorts and functional swimwear – replacing two separate pairs (one casual, one swim) with just one makes “cost per wear” much more cost-effective.
How can I get the best deal on Faherty clothing?
One sure-fire way of saving is with their first-time customer discount; LMM20 provides 20% off for newcomers! Also be sure to keep an eye out at the end of each season in their “Last Chance” section, where core staples often have discounts of 30-50%!
The Bottom Line
Faherty clothing occupies that sweet spot between premium quality and everyday wearability. It’s not cheap, but the sustainability story is genuine, the fabrics are best-in-class at this price point, and the pieces get better with wear rather than worse. If you’re building a capsule wardrobe of things that actually last, they belong in the conversation.
Rating: 8.5/10
