The 2026 Gift Guide is live
Get the free Fit & Fabric Checklist

Shawl Collar Cardigans: How to Wear One and 6 Picks

Where the shawl collar cardigan came from, how it should fit, what to look for in the knit, how to wear one, and six worth buying.

Some links earn us a commission at no cost to you. How we test

Chunky oatmeal shawl collar cardigan with horn buttons and patch pockets over a white tee and dark jeans
Illustration: Style & Serum
In this article

A shawl collar cardigan is a button front sweater with a wide, rolled collar. The collar runs from the neck down to the first button. It sits between a sweater and a jacket. Wear it over a tee, an oxford or a flannel with jeans or chinos. It does the job of a casual blazer.

Below: its history, the fit, what to look for, how to wear one, and six worth buying now.

Chunky oatmeal shawl collar cardigan with horn buttons and patch pockets over a white tee and dark jeans
Illustration: Style & Serum

Where the shawl collar cardigan came from

The cardigan is named after James Brudenell, the 7th Earl of Cardigan. He led the Charge of the Light Brigade at Balaclava in 1854, during the Crimean War. According to Country Life, he gave his men a knitted wool waistcoat to wear under their uniforms.

The story goes that the Earl later asked for a version with sleeves after a fire damaged his coat. Treat that one as legend. What is on record is that his fame after the war sold the garment. Merchants sold knitted cardigans, with and without sleeves, and they were soon made at commercial scale.

The shawl collar itself is older than the sweater version. You can see it on the smoking jacket, a velvet or silk lounge jacket designed in the 1850s. Wikipedia’s entry describes the traditional version with a shawl collar, turn up cuffs and toggle or button closures. The same rolled collar later showed up on the dinner jacket and the tuxedo.

Put the two together and you get knitwear with the outline of a lounge jacket. The cardigan’s history ties it to college dress in the 1920s and early 1930s, and it never really left. Today the style is made everywhere from Scottish mills to Italian knitters.

Shawl collar vs. a regular cardigan

A regular cardigan has a V neck or a crew neck and is usually thin. It layers under a jacket. A shawl collar cardigan is usually thicker, and the collar frames your face and neck. It is built to be the outer layer.

That collar is the whole point. Permanent Style argues it is the most versatile knit you can own. It works with T-shirts, shirts and polos alike. A V neck over a tee can leave the neck looking bare. The shawl collar fills that space.

How a shawl collar cardigan should fit

  • Shoulders: the seam should sit at or just past your shoulder bone. Chunky knits often have dropped shoulders, which is fine if the sleeves still end at the wrist.
  • Chest: buttoned, it should close without pulling across the buttons. Leave room for a flannel or an oxford underneath.
  • Length: the hem should land around the top of your back pockets. Much longer and it starts to read as a coat.
  • Sleeves: they should end at the wrist bone. Ribbed cuffs can be pushed up, so a little extra length is easier to live with than too little.
  • Collar: it should lie flat on your chest when the cardigan is open. A collar that stands up or flips is a sign of a cheap or poorly shaped knit.

Traditional Scottish knitwear is often cut generous in the waist. Permanent Style suggests sizing down in some of those cuts. Check each brand’s measurements before you order, and compare them to a sweater you already own.

Man buttoning a gray shawl collar cardigan over a dark shirt on a city sidewalk
Photo: Chad Madden / Unsplash

What to look for: fiber, weight and construction

Fiber. Wool is the classic choice. It is warm, holds its shape and resists odor. Lambswool is soft and affordable. Merino is finer and smoother. Cashmere is the softest and the most expensive, and it pills more if the yarn is short. Cotton works for mild climates and people who find wool itchy. Our natural fiber clothing guide goes deeper on wool, cotton and the rest.

Gauge and weight. Gauge is how many stitches fit in an inch. A low number like 3 gauge means thick yarn and a chunky knit. A higher number like 7 gauge is finer and dressier. Chunky knits replace a jacket. Finer ones layer under a coat.

Construction. Look for a collar knit as part of the body or fully fashioned, not a flat panel sewn on. Real horn or corozo buttons are a good sign. Patch pockets add a casual look and somewhere for your hands. Check the care label too. Most wool cardigans should be hand washed and dried flat. Our guide to washing cashmere at home covers the same method for wool.

How to wear a shawl collar cardigan

  • Over a white tee with jeans. The easiest look. Add leather boots or clean sneakers. A chunky knit in oatmeal or brown reads best here.
  • Over an oxford or flannel. Wear it open with the collar framing the shirt collar. Pair it with chinos or brown pants.
  • In place of a blazer. A finer knit in navy, gray or camel works for a casual office or dinner. Add a knit tie if you want to push it.
  • Under a coat. A thinner shawl cardigan fits under a peacoat or a barn jacket on cold days.
  • For the holidays. It is a natural fit for a family dinner. See our Thanksgiving outfits for full looks.

Keep the rest of the outfit simple. The collar is already the detail people notice. Want a heavier textured knit with a crew neck instead? Our fisherman sweater guide covers the Aran style.

6 shawl collar cardigans worth buying

Prices and stock were checked on each brand’s site on November 16, 2026. They are listed from lowest to highest price.

1. Faherty Chunky Indigo Cardigan in Windcliff Indigo Wash: $199 (was $348)

Chunky 100% organic cotton yarn, dyed with indigo. Five real horn buttons, rib stitch pockets and a 27.5 inch length in a classic fit, per Faherty. A good pick for warm climates or anyone who finds wool itchy. Only XS, S and XXL were in stock. Shop the Chunky Indigo Cardigan at Faherty

2. L.L.Bean Signature 1980 Matinicus Rock Cardigan: $180

100% wool in a birdseye jacquard knit. It has a button at the collar, patch pockets and faux horn buttons. L.L.Bean calls the fit slightly fitted and suggests sizing up for thick layers. It is machine washable, then dried flat. Shown in Deepest Brown Birdseye, XS to XXXL listed. Shop the Matinicus Rock Cardigan at L.L.Bean

3. Schott NYC SW2561 Cable Knit Cardigan: $190

From the peacoat and leather jacket maker. A midweight wool blend cable knit with five buttons, a shawl collar and patch pockets. Schott does not list the exact blend on the product page. Every size from S to 2XL was in stock in Burgundy, Moss and Off White. Shop the SW2561 at Schott NYC

4. Alex Mill Wallace Cardigan in Washed Cashmere: $378

2-ply washed cashmere in a 7 gauge knit, so it is finer and dressier than the chunky picks. Corozo buttons and Alex Mill’s X-stitch detail. The brand says it runs true to size. A Medium has a 42 inch chest and 27 inch length. Espresso had M, L and XL; Navy had S to XXL. For more cashmere options, see our best cashmere sweaters. Shop the Wallace Cardigan at Alex Mill

5. Drake’s Navy Lambswool Shawl Collar Cardigan: $755

100% lambswool, made in Scotland, with brown knotted leather buttons. Drake’s pitches it as an alternative to a tailored jacket on casual days. Drake’s US store also lists it in ecru and grey at the same price. Navy had XXS to XXL in stock. Ecru had S to L, and grey had XS, S and L. Shop the Navy Shawl Collar Cardigan at Drake’s

6. Wolf vs Goat Wool Chunky Shawl Collar Cardigan in Cocoa Powder: $595

The heaviest knit here. Zegna Baruffa Cashwool yarn in a 3 gauge, 12 ply Maglia Inglese stitch, made in Italy. Real horn buttons and front patch pockets. Only Small and Medium were in stock. More on the brand in our Wolf vs Goat guide. Shop the Chunky Shawl Collar Cardigan at Wolf vs Goat

FAQ

Are shawl collar cardigans still in style?

Yes. Drake’s, Alex Mill, L.L.Bean, Schott and Wolf vs Goat all sell one this season. The style has stayed in menswear since the 1920s because it works with so many outfits.

How should a shawl collar cardigan fit?

Shoulder seams sit at your shoulders and sleeves end at the wrist. The hem lands near the top of your back pockets. It should button without pulling, with room for a shirt underneath.

What do you wear under a shawl collar cardigan?

A white or gray tee, an oxford shirt, a flannel or a polo. The collar frames all of them. Skip a hooded layer, since it fights with the collar.

Can a shawl collar cardigan replace a blazer?

For casual settings, yes. Try a finer knit in navy, gray or camel with an oxford and chinos. It works for a relaxed office or dinner. It is not a substitute for a suit jacket at a formal event.

What is the best material for a shawl collar cardigan?

Wool is the classic choice for warmth and shape. Lambswool is a good value, cashmere is softest and cotton suits warm climates or people who find wool itchy.

Keep reading

Prices and stock as shown on each brand’s site on November 16, 2026.