I’ve been wearing Faherty clothing for about a year now, and people keep asking me whether it’s worth the price. Fair question — their shirts run $100+, shorts hover around $80-90, and outerwear can push past $300. That’s not impulse-buy territory for most people.
So here’s my honest take after putting their gear through a full four seasons of wear.
What Is Faherty?
Faherty is a premium lifestyle brand founded by twin brothers Alex and Mike Faherty in 2013. Their whole thing is sustainable, high-quality basics — the kind of clothes you’re supposed to reach for every single day. They use organic cotton, recycled materials, and responsible manufacturing. The vibe sits somewhere between coastal casual and refined everyday wear.
If you’ve ever searched for Faherty clothing online, you’ve probably noticed the brand popping up in menswear roundups alongside names like Vuori, Marine Layer, and Billy Reid. They compete in that “elevated casual” space that’s exploded post-pandemic.
Quality and Materials
This is where Faherty earns its price tag. The fabrics feel noticeably different from what you’ll find at J.Crew or Banana Republic. Their signature Legend sweater knit is probably the softest thing I own — it feels broken-in from day one but hasn’t degraded after dozens of washes.
Some of their button-downs use brushed cotton that drapes better than most shirts at twice the price. The stitching is clean, the buttons feel substantial, and the collars hold their shape. I’ve had a Faherty flannel for over a year with zero pilling.
Faherty uses different materials across its collections. Check each product’s composition and the brand’s impact reporting. Fabric softness alone does not establish a sustainability claim.
Fit and Sizing
Faherty runs true to size with a slightly relaxed fit. If you’re between sizes, I’d say stay true — the slight ease in the cut is part of the appeal. Their shorts hit right above the knee (7″ inseam on most styles), and their tees have a boxy-but-not-oversized silhouette that works on most body types.
One thing worth noting: their pants tend to run about a half-inch generous in the waist. Not enough to size down, but worth knowing if you’re between sizes.
What I’d Improve
The price is the obvious barrier. A $128 button-down is a tough sell when you can get “good enough” from Target for $30. You’re paying for sustainability, superior fabric, and longevity — but that premium is real.
Faherty now has more than 80 stores in the US, so you can try most pieces on before you buy. Online orders get a 60-day return window.
Is Faherty Worth It?
If you value quality over quantity and want a wardrobe of pieces that genuinely last, yes. I’ve replaced four “cheap” shirts with two Faherty shirts and I reach for the Faherty every time. A cost-per-wear comparison depends on the purchase price and how often you actually wear each piece.
Before buying, check Faherty’s current welcome offer and sale section. Eligibility and exclusions can change. Confirm any discount at checkout.
What’s new at Faherty for fall 2026
Faherty’s big fall story is a Made in Japan indigo capsule. The Indigo Sashiko Chore Jacket in Dark Indigo ($448) is 100 percent indigo-dyed cotton. The Selvedge 5-Pocket Denim in Indigo Rinse Wash ($348) is a 13 oz organic cotton selvedge.
For everyday wear, the Japanese Flannel Workshirt in Blue Sora Plaid ($248) is all cotton. The Stretch Terry Corduroy Workshirt in Deep Moss ($198) is 98 percent organic cotton with a little stretch.
The Legend Sweater Shirt is back in new colors at $178. The Cedar Ombre Plaid Legend shirt contains 64% recycled polyester, 34% viscose and 2% elastane. Other Legend versions use different blends. It is soft and easy, but it is not a natural fiber shirt.
Faherty shipping, returns and stores in 2026
Shipping is free on orders over $150 in the contiguous US. Returns and exchanges are open for 60 days on unworn, unwashed items with tags. Final sale items cannot be returned. Faherty provides a prepaid return label, but original shipping is not refunded.
Faherty is no longer an online-first brand. It had more than 80 US stores in early 2026, and Forbes reported it expects close to 100 by the end of the year. In March 2026 it announced its first store outside the US, in Biarritz, France.
Faherty has been a certified B Corporation since July 2024. It also runs Second Wave, a program for buying, selling and trading in worn Faherty pieces.
Fabric, care and size details checked October 12, 2026. Prices and policies were checked on fahertybrand.com September 29, 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Faherty clothing shrink after the first wash?
Follow the care label for your specific item. Faherty recommends a cold, gentle wash and low dryer heat for the Cedar Ombre Plaid Legend shirt. Remove it promptly after drying. Do not assume one shrinkage rate applies across every Faherty fabric.
How does Faherty sizing compare to brands like J.Crew or Marine Layer?
Use Faherty’s measurements rather than a direct size conversion from another brand. Its men’s tops chart lists medium for a 40 to 41 inch chest. Large covers 42 to 44 inches. Measure around your chest and check the specific item’s fit notes.
What exactly is the “Legend” fabric everyone talks about?
Legend is Faherty’s double knit fabric family. The Cedar Ombre Plaid shirt uses 64% recycled polyester, 34% viscose and 2% elastane. Other versions use different blends. Check your chosen style and color before buying.
Is Faherty considered a “Fast Fashion” brand?
Faherty offers a resale marketplace through Second Wave. Check each product’s materials and the brand’s impact reporting rather than relying on a broad label.
Are Faherty shorts worth the price?
Value depends on the specific shorts and how you plan to wear them. Check their fabric, inseam, waistband and care details. Do not assume every Faherty short works as swimwear.
How can I get the best deal on Faherty clothing?
Check Faherty’s current welcome offer and sale section before ordering. Eligibility and exclusions can change. Confirm the discount at checkout.
The Bottom Line
Faherty clothing occupies that sweet spot between premium quality and everyday wearability. It’s not cheap, but the sustainability story is genuine, the fabrics are best-in-class at this price point, and wear and care affect each piece differently. If you’re building a capsule wardrobe of things that actually last, they belong in the conversation.
Rating: 8.5/10
Keep reading
