The 2026 Gift Guide is live
Get the free Fit & Fabric Checklist

Taylor Stitch Review: The Ojai Jacket and Cutter Overshirt, Bought at Full Price

I paid full price for the Ojai Jacket and the Cutter Overshirt. Here is how they fit, how they held up and what to know before you buy.

Some links earn us a commission at no cost to you. How we test

Young man in a green and tan plaid overshirt worn open over a black tee against a pale blue wall
Photo: Prateek Saxena / Unsplash
In this article

In the spring of 2008, three friends shared an apartment in San Francisco. It sat at the corner of Taylor and Clay streets. They set out to make the best custom shirt they could, Remodelista reported in 2013. Thousands of custom shirts later, they sized their shirts like jackets. “You buy our shirts by your chest size,” co-founder Michael Maher told Entrepreneur.

That chest number is the first thing to know before you buy. I own two Taylor Stitch pieces: a tan Ojai Jacket and the Cutter Overshirt in Buzzard Check. I bought both at full price. Some links below are affiliate links, which earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

The short version: both fit true to size in a Large. Neither has shrunk, and I have had no wear issues so far. I give them 5 out of 5, and I would buy both again at full price.

Young man in a green and tan plaid overshirt worn open over a black tee against a pale blue wall
Photo: Prateek Saxena / Unsplash

At a glance

How I got themBought both at full price
The piecesOjai Jacket in tan; Cutter Overshirt in Buzzard Check
How long I’ve had themOjai: several months. Cutter: about two months as of late October
My sizeLarge in both
FitTrue to size
ShrinkageNone
CareTaylor Stitch says wash cold and tumble dry low
Wear issuesNone so far
Score5 out of 5
Buy againYes, at full price

The Ojai Jacket

Mine is a tan Ojai in a Large, and I have had it for several months.

The Ojai is an unlined jacket with a single chest pocket and two lower patch pockets. Its tan versions, such as Light Khaki and Dried Earth, were 8 oz organic cotton twill. Both are now sold out and archived on Taylor Stitch’s site.

The same 8 oz organic cotton twill now comes in navy, smoked olive and charcoal for $198. Every size of the Ojai in Smoked Olive was in stock on November 19. There is also a 12 oz organic cotton corduroy version for $248, like the Ojai in Soil Corduroy. Soil Corduroy was sold out in small on November 19, so check your size first. The product pages list both versions as made in China.

Our Taylor Stitch Ojai Jacket review goes deeper on the corduroy colors and six ways to wear one.

A man with his hands in the pockets of Taylor Stitch’s Ojai Jacket in Light Khaki Foundation Twill, worn over jeans
The Ojai Jacket in Light Khaki Foundation Twill, a tan version that is now sold out. Photo: Taylor Stitch

The Cutter Overshirt

My Cutter is in Buzzard Check, a green check, in a Large. By late October I had owned it for about two months.

Taylor Stitch lists the Cutter Overshirt in Buzzard Check at $178. Its product page describes a 12.5 oz oversized twill in 100% organic cotton. The cotton is certified to the Global Organic Textile Standard, the page says. It has two buttoned chest pockets and is made in China.

Taylor Stitch says the Cutter is fitted at the chest and straighter through the body. Every size of the Buzzard Check was in stock on November 19.

The Cutter in Lighthouse Check had every size too, also at $178. So did Beachwood Check and Forester Check.

A man in Taylor Stitch’s Cutter Overshirt in Buzzard Check, an olive, brown and cream check, with gray trousers
The Cutter Overshirt in Buzzard Check. Photo: Taylor Stitch

How I wear them

I usually wear the Ojai over just a T-shirt.

The Cutter goes with jeans or cords and a tee underneath, usually white or green. Lately the cords are two thrifted pairs, one green and one dark maroon. The tags were gone, so I can’t tell you the brand.

I own more Buck Mason than Taylor Stitch, so Buck Mason wins on count. But I prefer my Taylor Stitch pieces, and I want to reach for them more than I can. Our Buck Mason vs Taylor Stitch comparison goes category by category. For more ways to wear a shirt like the Cutter, see our overshirt guide.

Man in a gray plaid overshirt worn open over a white tee, with brown trousers and tan suede shoes, leaning on a white wall
Photo: Hannah Busing / Unsplash

Fit and sizing

Taylor Stitch sizes its tops by chest. Its body chart puts a Large at a 42 inch chest. XS is 36, S is 38, M is 40, XL is 44 and XXL is 46.

That chart measures you, not the garment. The size guides on the product pages also list garment sizes. At a Large, the Cutter’s chest is 46.5 inches and the Ojai’s is 47.

I wear a Large in both, and both fit true to size. If you are between sizes, Taylor Stitch’s fit guide says to size up. It also says its overshirts fit more like a light jacket than a shirt.

Most of its garments are washed before they reach you, so some shrinkage has already happened, the brand says. Our size guide compares how 30 brands fit in a Large.

Man in sunglasses wearing a cream plaid overshirt over a mustard tee and beige trousers in a park
Photo: Babak Eshaghian / Unsplash

How they have held up

Neither piece has shrunk, and I have had no wear issues so far.

Taylor Stitch gives the same care advice for both: wash cold and tumble dry low. If something does fail, its Long Haul Guarantee applies. The brand says it repairs or replaces defects outside normal wear, for the product’s expected life.

Price, returns and sales

The Cutter is $178. The Ojai is $198 in twill and $248 in corduroy.

Taylor Stitch’s return policy gives you 21 days from delivery. You can get a refund or store credit. It has to be unworn and unwashed, with the tags on. Return shipping is free within the continental U.S. That window is far shorter than Buck Mason’s 365 days, so try things on the day they arrive.

Last Call sells limited stock at lower prices, and it is final sale. Last Call items take no extra discounts and can only be swapped for another size. If something you bought goes on sale within 7 days, you get the difference as store credit, not cash. The site takes one discount code per order.

In 2019, Maher told Entrepreneur that much of the line was crowdfunded through Workshop, its pre-order program. The Workshop pages on its site now return an error.

For Black Friday, check our Black Friday men’s clothing deals page. Taylor Stitch is one of the first brands I plan to stock up on this year.

Who should buy, and who should skip

Buy Taylor Stitch if you want natural fiber layers that fit like light jackets. More than 99% of its cotton products now use 100% organic cotton, per the brand. In 2017 that share was 0%, Maher told Entrepreneur. Our natural fiber clothing guide explains why that matters.

Skip it if you need a long return window, because 21 days goes fast. And skip Last Call if you might change your mind, since it is final sale.

Frequently asked questions

Is Taylor Stitch worth it?

For me, yes. I paid full price for the Ojai Jacket and the Cutter Overshirt. Both fit true to size, neither has shrunk, and I would buy both again at full price. The trade-offs are a 21-day return window and final-sale markdowns.

Does Taylor Stitch run small?

Not in my experience. I wear a Large in both pieces, and both fit true to size. Taylor Stitch sizes tops by chest, so a Large is for a 42 inch chest. If you are between sizes, its help center says to size up.

Does Taylor Stitch go on sale?

Yes, in limited ways. Last Call sells limited stock at lower prices, and it is final sale. If an item drops in price within 7 days of your order, you get the difference in store credit. The site allows one discount code per order.

Where is Taylor Stitch made?

The Cutter and the current Ojai Jacket are listed as made in China on Taylor Stitch’s product pages. Its responsibility page also describes its own factory, Hubo, which it says pays living wages.

Prices, sizes and stock as shown on Taylor Stitch’s site on November 19, 2026.

Keep reading