The best gift for a boyfriend is one he wears the next day. These 25 picks are sorted by budget. Each one includes a sizing tip, because a gift in the wrong size lives in a drawer. For more ideas, see our full gift guide for men.
Most of these are natural fibers from brands I trust. Several I own and wear every week, and I say so where that is the case.
Under $50
Comrad Trail Compression Crew, $35
A sock sounds boring until he wears a good one. The Comrad Trail Compression Crew blends merino with nylon for stretch and has targeted compression around the Achilles area, according to Comrad. It is made in the USA.
Sizing tip: between sizes? Comrad says size down for a tighter feel or up for comfort.
Buck Mason Slub Classic Tee in Olive Drab, $48
I own this tee in several colors. The Buck Mason Slub Classic Tee is a 145 GSM slub jersey knit at Buck Mason’s own mill in Pennsylvania. It is garment washed, so it comes soft.
Sizing tip: it is a classic fit with a straight hem. Buy his usual tee size.
Faherty Sunwashed Twill Baseball Hat, $48
The Faherty Sunwashed Twill Baseball Hat in Coastal Sage is 100 percent cotton with a sun-faded finish. It looks a year old on day one.
Sizing tip: one size with an adjustable buckle.
R+Co Rockaway Salt Spray, $32
For the guy with short, thick hair. R+Co Rockaway Salt Spray adds texture and a little hold without the crunch of gel. The sea salt spray guide compares it with other picks.
Sizing tip: none needed. The bottle is 4.2 oz.
Jungmaven Walla Walla Beanie, $38
The Jungmaven Walla Walla Beanie in Navy is a hemp and wool blend in a classic fisherman shape.
Sizing tip: Jungmaven says it runs a bit oversized and roomy.
Sid Mashburn Bandana in Navy Paisley, $35
A cotton bandana is a pocket square, a sweat rag and a dog scarf. The Sid Mashburn Bandana in Navy Paisley is 100 percent cotton.
Sizing tip: one size.
Tanner Goods Single Wrap Wristband, $40
The Tanner Goods Single Wrap Wristband in Saddle Tan uses the same leather as Tanner Goods belts. Pick stainless, brass, copper or black hardware.
Sizing tip: small fits a 7.75 inch wrist, medium 8.25 and large 8.75. Measure one of his watch straps.
Under $100
Faherty Long-Sleeve Cloud Henley, $98
I own two of these. The Faherty Long-Sleeve Cloud Henley in Deep Olive Feeder is Pima cotton and modal with raglan sleeves and a three-button placket.
Sizing tip: classic fit. Faherty’s 6 foot model wears a medium.
Katin Derek Flannel, $79
The Katin Derek Flannel in Olive is a light cotton flannel with a brushed finish and an enzyme wash. It is the right weight for a warm fall.
Sizing tip: Katin’s 6 foot model wears a medium.
3sixteen Watch Cap, $75 on sale
The 3sixteen Watch Cap in Pewter Tweed is alpaca and wool, knit in Peru. It was $75 on September 29, down from $99. Sale items at 3sixteen are final.
Sizing tip: one size, long enough for a single fold or a double cuff.
Buck Mason Toughknit Tubular Tee 2-Pack, $88
The Buck Mason Toughknit Tubular Tee 2-Pack in White is 160 GSM American-grown, ring-spun cotton knit as a tube, so it has no side seams; this does not guarantee the fabric can never twist.
Sizing tip: classic fit. Buy his usual size.
Sid Mashburn Bombay Stitch Belt, $65
The Sid Mashburn 1 inch Bombay Stitch Belt in Havana Bridle is bridle leather with stitched edges. The brass buckle snaps off, so it can be swapped later.
Sizing tip: sizes run 30 to 42. Check the size printed inside his current belt.
Katin Swell Sweater, $89
The Katin Swell Sweater in Tempest Blue is 100 percent cotton with Katin’s vintage wash. It is a cotton sweater for a guy who runs warm.
Sizing tip: Katin does not give fit notes for this one. Match the size of his favorite sweatshirt.
Billykirk No. 397 Slim Card Case, $85
The Billykirk No. 397 Slim Card Case in Dark Brown is vegetable-tanned leather, hand stitched with waxed cord. It holds five to seven cards.
Sizing tip: none needed.
Under $200
Faherty Lehi Canyon Overshirt, $198
I own this one. The Faherty Lehi Canyon Overshirt in Uzumate is organic cotton with button-flap chest pockets. He can wear it open over a tee most of the year. The overshirt guide has more options.
Sizing tip: Faherty’s 6 foot 1 model wears a medium.
Save Khaki United Weekend Chino, $180
The Save Khaki United Weekend Chino in Khaki is garment-dyed cotton twill with a button fly, made in the USA from imported fabric.
Sizing tip: it is a wide stovepipe leg. Save Khaki’s 6 foot 1 models wear a 32 waist.
Sid Mashburn Low-Top Lace-Up Sneaker, $195
The Sid Mashburn Low-Top Lace-Up Sneaker in Navy Suede has a suede upper, a calf leather lining and a white rubber sole. It is made in Portugal and ships with two sets of laces.
Sizing tip: check the tongue of his favorite sneaker for his size, then use Mashburn’s size guide.
Buck Mason Seafarer Cotton Rib Crew, $188
I own the Seafarer. The Buck Mason Seafarer Cotton Rib Crew in Tobacco is a 7-gauge cotton rib with hand-linked seams. It is a cotton sweater that still looks like a real sweater.
Sizing tip: classic fit. Buy his usual size.
Faherty Whitewater Hoodie, $188
I own two. The Faherty Whitewater Hoodie in Forest Grove is a popover with no drawcord, a kangaroo pocket and a vented hem. It is 75 percent organic cotton and 25 percent recycled polyester.
Sizing tip: relaxed fit. Faherty’s 6 foot 1 model wears a medium.
Knickerbocker Heirloom Flat Knit Thermal, $125
The Knickerbocker Heirloom Flat Knit Thermal in Oat Grey is a 310 GSM cotton rib, cut and sewn in Portugal with flatlock seams.
Sizing tip: it has a longer body and a closer fit. Size up if he likes room.
Splurge
Todd Snyder Cashmere Crewneck, $328
I own several Todd Snyder cashmere sweaters. The Todd Snyder Cashmere Crewneck in Tobacco is fully fashioned with a tubular hem.
Sizing tip: Todd Snyder tags this one as a slim fit. Size up if he is between sizes.
If $328 is too much, the Collars & Co Luxury Touch Cotton and Cashmere Crew is $118 and crazy soft. My Collars & Co review has a note on the oatmeal color, so pick navy, grey or black for a gift.
Alex Mill Garment Dyed Chore Jacket, $225
The Alex Mill Garment Dyed Chore Jacket in French Navy is lightweight cotton canvas with corozo buttons and four front pockets. It layers over a hoodie or a flannel. The chore coat guide compares it with other coats.
Sizing tip: Alex Mill says true to size. Its 6 foot 3 model wears a medium.
Grant Stone Diesel Boot, $435
The Grant Stone Diesel Boot in Crimson Chromexcel is Horween leather on a Goodyear welt. The welt means a cobbler can resole it.
Sizing tip: Grant Stone says the Leo last runs a half size large. Most customers go a half size down from their usual size.
Save Khaki United Wide Wale Corduroy Trucker, $240
The Save Khaki United Wide Wale Corduroy Trucker in Mocha Brown is 8-wale cotton corduroy, garment dyed and pre-shrunk, with four working pockets. The corduroy jacket guide has more.
Sizing tip: Save Khaki describes it as relaxed. Buy his usual size.
3sixteen Type 3s Denim Jacket, $290
The 3sixteen Type 3s Denim Jacket in Raw Indigo is 14.5 oz Japanese denim woven in Okayama and sewn in the USA. Raw denim fades to his shape over time.
Sizing tip: 3sixteen lists garment measurements. A medium is 22 inches across the chest. Lay his favorite jacket flat and compare.
How to get his size right
Check the tag on the tee or jacket he wears most. That is his real size, not the one he says out loud.
For pants, check the waist and inseam printed inside his favorite pair. For shoes, check the tongue of the sneakers he wears daily.
When in doubt, pick a brand with a long return window. Buck Mason takes returns for a year and Faherty for 60 days. Knickerbocker gives only five days to request a return and charges a restocking fee, so be sure before you order there.
Frequently asked questions
What do boyfriends want for Christmas?
Most men want better versions of what they already wear. A great tee, a soft henley, a good overshirt or a warm sweater gets worn the next day.
What is a good gift for a new boyfriend?
Keep it under $100 and low pressure. A beanie, a good tee, a salt spray or quality socks all work. Save the cashmere for later.
How much should you spend on a boyfriend gift?
There is no rule. Most of the picks here land between $35 and $200. Spend what fits your budget and your relationship, then pick quality at that price.
What clothes make good gifts for a boyfriend?
Pieces with forgiving fits. Overshirts, hoodies, sweaters, beanies and hats are hard to get wrong. Pants and shoes need exact sizes, so check his closet first.
Prices and stock as shown on each brand’s site on October 13, 2026. Check the product page before you buy, since holiday prices change.
Keep reading
